Four reasons why Rodrygo deserves to start for Real Madrid ahead of Vinicius

Xabi Alonso now has the responsibility of deciding Real Madrid’s attacking balance. The left-wing slot has traditionally belonged to Vinicius Jr. in recent seasons, and deservedly so. But his performances over the past year have left a lot to be desired. While he has shown glimpses of his best version, it has come sparingly and consistently enough. Meanwhile, Rodrygo, having stayed at Real Madrid during the summer, is now pushing for a starting berth on the left, competing with Vinicius. Having come off the bench against Kairat Almaty on Tuesday, the 24-year-old forward played a key role in Real Madrid’s third goal before setting Eduardo Camavinga for the fourth, presenting himself as a compelling alternative for the left-wing slot. Here are four reasons why he should start ahead of his compatriot. Superior chemistry with Mbappe When Real Madrid signed Kylian Mbappe, the club did not just add another superstar, they changed the shape of their attack. The pairing of the Frenchman with Vinicius was certainly a mouth-watering one on paper, but it has not always clicked on the field. Vinicius thrives when paired on a traditional No. 9 to maximize his game. His most devastating partnership came with Karim Benzema. By March of the 2021/22 season, the duo had already combined for eight goals – the most in Europe’s top five leagues at the time. By the end of that year, they’d assisted each other 18 times, the highest tally of any duo in Europe. Those numbers underline Vinicius’ reliance on a classic all-around striker. Rodrygo seems to work better with Mbappe than Vini. (Photo by Denis Doyle/Getty Images) With Benzema gone and Mbappe leading the line, that old formula does not work the same way. Rodrygo, on the other hand, thrives in fluid combinations, quick exchanges, and off-ball runs – exactly what Mbappe needs alongside him. Added value in set pieces Games are often decided by small margins, and set pieces are one of those margins. Rodrygo offers more in this area: he has shown competence in delivering precise corners or threatening free kicks. With Dani Carvajal aging, and Trent Alexander-Arnold not guaranteed to start every week due to injuries or tactical rotations, Real Madrid will often need someone reliable to step up over dead balls. Rodrygo’s ability to add that extra layer of threat makes him more valuable as a starter. Aerial presence Looking at Real Madrid’s likely front three of Mbappe, Vinicius, and Franco Mastantuono, none of them is known for aerial dominance. This has reduced the reliance on crosses into the box – something that their right-back, Trent, excels at, but it also makes them one-dimensional at times. Rodrygo offers a rare alternative – he is strong in the air and knows how to attack crosses. That unforgettable header against Manchester City in 2022 was not a fluke. Adding him into the lineup could add another dimension to Madrid’s attacking play. Competitive pressure to elevate performance Healthy competition could benefit everyone. (Photo by Juan Manuel Serrano Arce/Getty Images) Vinicius has long held the left-wing role as his by default. While deserving, that security can dull the competitive edge. If Rodrygo is given the starting nod, it does not signal a rejection of Vinicius – it demands accountability. The 25-year-old would need to make a stronger case during his substitute appearances; Rodrygo would need to sustain high levels over more minutes. That kind of internal competition sharpens standards and keeps complacency in check. Addressing the counterarguments There is no denying that that Vinicius offers more raw creativity, unpredictability, and relentless directness. That is true – his one-on-one ability and sheer explosiveness are unmatched. But those qualities do not always translate into balance when paired with Mbappe. Real Madrid risk becoming predictable if both rely on similar moves. Others may suggest Rodrygo lacks consistency, which has been the case this year. But consistency is often the product of rhythm and trust; giving him more starts could be the key to unlocking his full reliability. Furthermore, Rodrygo’s tactical discipline and defensive work rate also gives him the edge in staying compact when Real Madrid are under pressure.